Mr. Redlegs is watching you. Always.
Wednesday, May 2, 2012
Review of the Reds' April Offense
12-11 in 2010
14-13 in 2011 (1-0 in March, 13-13 in April)
11-11 in 2012
As we all know, they went on to quite different fates in 2010 and 2011, so it's worth taking a look at some of the overall trends. I'll keep each summary brief. Let me start by saying that OPS+ (adjusted on base plus slugging percentage) was the main metric I used, and for splits, the sOPS+ (relative to the league average for that particular split). In both cases, 100 would be a league average score, with a higher score being preferred.
One caveat - the Reds have started somewhat slowly on offense in each season, so comparing April numbers to full seasons of work isn't entirely fair. Therefore, I considered only the trends which are so numerically striking that they can't be explained away with the smaller difference month-to-month. A drop or rise of only 10-15 points in OPS+ wouldn't be significant enough to warrant discussion until later this season.
BATTING ORDER:
The Reds continue to have a ton of trouble with the 1st and 4th positions in the lineup.
Leadoff:
2010 sOPS+ = 92
2011 = 113
2012 = 8 (not a misprint)
Cleanup:
2010 sOPS+ = 98
2011 = 78
2012 = 49
The leadoff problem is not confined to Stubbs, although he is the worst offender - Cozart and Phillips haven't performed well either in their roughly equal share of the plate appearances.
The cleanup position should be kept out of Rolen's hands for good - he has an alarming minus-12 sOPS+ batting in the #4 spot this season. BP or Bruce would serve us better in that spot.
BY DEFENSIVE POSITION:
Five of the eight non-pitching positions have an alarming downward trend since 2010. Catcher and second base are less worrisome, due to talent, track record and simply higher scores than the other positions. We can have reasonable confidence that Hanigan, Mesoraco and BP, if all remain healthy enough, will put up solid enough offensive numbers to justify inclusion in the lineup.
The same cannot be said for the other three problem positions, which we all know by heart at this point:
3B, LF and CF.
Third base:
2010 = 122
2011 = 94
2012 = 46
Left field:
2010 = 101
2011 = 88
2012 = 56
Center field:
2010 = 105
2011 = 97
2012 = 55
SITUATIONAL TRENDS:
Positive changes:
High-leverage sOPS+ = 110 - 102 - 127 (in 2010, 2011 and 2012, respectively)
sOPS+ when leading off innings = 105 - 97 - 123
Negative changes:
sOPS+ with RISP: 113 - 109 - 86
sOPS+ with 2 OUT: 119 - 96 - 78
sOPS+ in Night games: 116 - 98 - 67
sOPS+ leading off the game: 109 - 102 - 49
Conclusions:
None of these trends should really come as a surprise. We knew that the personnel on this team had some offensive flaws. 1B, SS and RF look very promising both short- and long-term. C and 2B should be okay. 3B, LF and CF are true problems, and are strongly interconnected with the leadoff and cleanup inadequacy.
Sunday, July 3, 2011
Fred Lewis for leadoff
Among our current choices, I don't really feel there's a good argument for anyone else.
Consider this:
If you look at the career stats of EVERY single position player on the team, there are only TWO who have higher career OBP leading off innings than their overall career OBP. Most are significantly worse starting things off, including Votto.
The two exceptions are:
Scott Rolen (only .002 higher, and not exactly someone you want leading off)
and
Fred Lewis (.349 overall, .371 leading off innings)
The trend has continued this season, albeit in a small sample size so far. He's got a .391 OBP in 23 such plate appearances.
Heisey: .178 (45 PA)
Stubbs: .286 (147 PA)
While I never want to see him batting 1st (or really in the lineup at all) against lefties, he should be seeing the majority of the time at leadoff unless we make a roster change or Stubbs somehow makes a massive turnaround.
Leadoff batters typically get 1/3 (or more) of their plate appearances leading off innings, while batters in other positions in the order only about 20-25%.
Saturday, June 25, 2011
Leadoff Hitters and First Inning Offense
In fact, among the past 20 World Series winners (beginning with the Reds, ending with the Giants) five had equal or worse leadoff batter OBPs. Not that it's Hall of Fame company - Dan Gladden, Andres Torres, Luis Castillo, Devon White and Marquis Grissom.
In looking at these statistics I happened upon one other comparison between the current Reds and past champions, which is less favorable. All of the recent champions have been strong offensively in the first inning, scoring an average of 12.68% of their runs in that frame.
The lowest percentage, and only one under 10%, belonged to the 1996 New York Yankees (9.64%). Checking in at a whopping 17.84% were the 1997 Marlins - curiously so, considering their poor leadoff performance that season.
Our beloved Redlegs have been slow starters in 2011. After posting a respectable first inning run total in 2010, only 8.99% of their runs (34 of 378) have come in the opening inning this year.
As an inevitable result, the opposition has scored first in 62% of the games (48 of 78) and the Reds are 22-26 in those contests, only achieving such a decent record because of their late inning heroics.
Want specific players to blame? Among the three players with the most first inning at-bats, only Brandon Phillips hits well (.308 BA). Stubbs is an abysmal .177 and Votto an uncharacteristic .262 (but his OBP is still .395).
Guys like Jay Bruce (.292) and Scott Rolen (.267) likely have their statistics skewed upward by the fact they would only bat in the first if the Reds are succeeding against the pitcher.
In conclusion, we're still searching for our man at leadoff. Heisey may have hit pretty well now for a few games, but he's still only 2 for 11 in the first inning.
I've long thought that we should give Fred Lewis a shot now and then, as he does boast a career leadoff average higher than his overall average, and if I recall correctly he is the ONLY player on the Reds' roster with such a statistic.
This may (hopefully) become moot, with the (hopefully) imminent arrival of Dave Sappelt. Zack Cozart is another player with potential to give the Reds' inconsistent offense a shot in the arm, but that's a discussion for another day.